FreeTube: Is It Down For Me Or For Everyone?

Got an update right now. yt-dlpwork as expected again

2 Likes

I’m sure with Google testing their A.I crap it will only be a matter of time before we are back here with crap not working.

1 Like

With the current Global Corporation Tyranny, every inch of your life should be under control. Even what, where, when and how you consume.

Good Luck with that.

They will get there. We are just some species on the verge of extinction. I know I sound pessimist but unless I see some serious sign of “going against the stream” from the younger generations…

Anyways, this can get into subject matters that will cause breach of forum laws.

3 Likes

A dependency has been created. That could imply consumer dependency (can’t give it up), but it could also imply that some things we value can’t be got any other way (eg: content creators who only publish to YouTube).

I expect many of us here have our reasons for choosing not to use YouTube proper, and yet, not using it at all is still something difficult to do, because of that dependency.

Now imagine a generation who shares no such qualms, as to @cactux’s point.

2 Likes

Yes, you have a point about the dependency.

Honestly, since this thing started happening yesterday and the awkwardness of the workarounds for watching some content, it was also a bit of relief. I spent less time in front of the screen and more time inside my own head.

Yes there are things we value that cannot be get any other way, but I am thinking, speaking for and to myself, that perhaps the time has come for me to reevaluate the things I value, generally speaking and more specifically when it comes to my consumption of content or otherwise.

2 Likes

Wise words my friend :purple_heart: :handshake:

1 Like

As far as that I am talking only ME. lol. No way the new world will get away with what we have. I don’t have apps on my phone I don’t have a “smart” anything. (well tv but its in the closet unplugged) Even the people I lease from are replacing things with older non smart stuff. (an harder and harder find) Which means there is a market for it so anyone looking to go into business.

2 Likes

I don’t even have a smart phone, I have one of these from 2018:

I do have a no-brand tablet though, for note taking primarily.

2 Likes

For my use case, the issue I have with grayjay is that it doesn’t have proxy support as far as I can tell.

So I would still be downloading videos directly from youtube which is only moderately better from a privacy perspective.

2 Likes

Right, it doesn’t support proxy. Would be a nice feature.

Also, lately I have been thinking of proxychains-ng to proxy mpv/yt-dlp. And I did try it but I wasn’t able to make it work. It should be pretty straight forward and I had done it before, quite a long time ago now, but now it just hangs.

yt-dlp has native support for a proxy. It is a command line option, --proxy.

2 Likes

Ah. I didn’t know that. That’s great! So it should be possible to run it over proxy and pipe it into mpv. I know it sounds a bit awkward but I am just being curious about the options we have.

1 Like

I have never tried that. Let me know if it works. :slight_smile:

1 Like
--proxy URL
              Use the specified HTTP/HTTPS/SOCKS proxy.  To enable SOCKS proxy, specify a proper scheme, e.g.  socks5://user:pass@127.0.0.1:1080/

So I tried:

yt-dlp --proxy socks5://user:pass@127.0.0.1:9050 https://youtu.be/EcQi49G-5cI

and it seems to be working as it was painfully slow to download an small size video:

[download] 100% of 23.72MiB in 00:02:08 at 189.18KiB/s

Also for piping it into mpv:

yt-dlp -o - --proxy socks5://user:pass@127.0.0.1:9050 https://youtu.be/EcQi49G-5cI | mpv -

should work. In principle, because I already got:

Sign in to confirm you’re not a bot.

:sweat_smile:

However, without --proxy, the following works:

yt-dlp -o - https://youtu.be/EcQi49G-5cI | mpv -

This is what I used yesterday with the addition of the “workaround” mentioned above to stream the videos instead of downloading.

Edit: I can confirm that after restarting the proxy a couple of times, it works as “advertised” :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

1 Like

I’ve had a pretty rough go with freetube for quite a while now to be honest.

Yeah I think you’re right @dalto, in terms of proxy support. GrayJay desktop has an internal proxy, presumably for routing connectins internally to the various streaming services. This is just how it handles requests internally. That’s quite different to the remote proxy I suspect you’re referring to.

A system wide VPN / proxy overcomes this of course, assuming one is happy to use those.

Yeah, I pass my youtube traffic over TOR. I definitely don’t want all my traffic going over TOR though.

1 Like

that in the output makes me worry :slight_smile:

what is up with this big YT crackdown?

I’ve seen this discussed in this thread. you like the program?