For phonon-qt5
, you have the choice to use phonon-qt5-gstreamer
or phonon-qt5-vlc
as the backend. This is not the case for phonon-qt6
, which only has one backend provider in the official repos: phonon-qt6-vlc
If you have any KDE applications that depends on phonon-qt6
, pacman will end up installing vlc
on your system if you don’t already have it installed—because phonon-qt6
depends on phonon-qt6-vlc
, which in turns requires vlc
.
For mpv
users, there is the option of using phonon-qt6-mpv-git
in the AUR as the backend. This allows you to run applications that depends on phonon-qt6
without having to keep vlc
on your system.
https://jriddell.org/2023/11/02/phonon-4-12-0-and-phonon-vlc-0-12-0/
https://bbs.archlinux.org/viewtopic.php?pid=2155282#p2155282
5 Likes
So that means I first install phonon-qt6-mpv-git
so that the dependencies are still fulfilled and then I uninstall vlc
including all photon-qt5
packages and orphans left behind?
Or I’ll wait until vlc
can finally keep up with mpv
again in terms of quality and let it bumble along on my system …
Not quite.
Install phonon-qt6-mpv-git
first.
Then uninstall phonon-qt6-vlc
After you have uninstalled phonon-qt6-vlc
then:
Uninstall vlc
.
1 Like
May I ask why you prefer mpv over vlc?
(Perhaps related to the topic: nothing prevents the screen to go to sleep while playing vlc since the Plasma 6 update.)
@Alexandre mpv
is more configurable and lightweight compared to vlc
. You can verify the latter by comparing the install sizes of both packages in the extra
repo.
I don’t have any problems with vlc
per se, but I prefer something less bloated. Also, in my experience, mpv
has better performance on older hardware compared to vlc
, most likely because it is less bloated.
2 Likes
I also didn’t want VLC on my machine and unfortunately MPV backend is very buggy and doesn’t work reliably for me. So I decided to try to patch that gstreamer package to build using Qt6 for Plasma 6 and somehow I succeeded
Feel free to try my AUR package, it really needs some community testing: https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/phonon-qt6-gstreamer-git
2 Likes
No matter how I set vlc, I always notice a slight jerking and stuttering of the video image (mostly mkv
). With mpv, everything runs smoothly and without complaint. I don’t care about the interface with all the setting options if the performance is what I need. I don’t necessarily have the worst graphics card (RX 580, RX 6600 XT is planned soon), but vlc always ticks around in some way. Just a legacy issue for me …
sorry for offtopic
1 Like
I just installed phonon-qt6-gstreamer-git 4.10.0_r3316.g2bfadef4-1
, just to finally get rid of VLC. So far everything seems to work fine. I’ll probably only be able to find out more in a long-term test, but so far I’m very happy with it thank you for this!