KDE Theming

Hi all,
For some months now the Global Theme section in KDE settings seems to be broken.
So many theme installations fail (pop ups giving various reasons). These aren’t old themes I’m trying to install, it seems to happen with anything.
Just occasionally if the stars align and with a fair tailwind a theme will install.
I used to be able to scroll pages and pages of themes, now it stops scrolling after about a page and a half. Same applies to icons, plasma themes, window decorations etc.
Obviously I could just download the themes from the KDE store instead but I’m just curious if any of you themers and ricers have experienced the above.

Edit: Actually when I download a global theme from the KDE Store website and unzip it all that’s in there is the look and feel stuff, there seem to be no components. Sorry I’m not good on the terminology.
So for example, a properly installed global theme looks like this..

If I download it from the website and unzip it it only contains this…

1 Like

It sounds like you are only downloading the look-and-feel (“Global”) themes and not the components they rely on, ie; color-scheme, desktoptheme, etc.

Global themes are a collection of Plasma theming components collectively applied. Like going through System Settings and applying ‘this’ then ‘this’ then ‘that’. If you dont have any of ‘those’ things then the global theme cant do much.

2 Likes

Ah yes, I see what you mean. Thanks.
Shame about the KDE settings/global themes app being so janky, it used to just install global themes so easily.

2 Likes

Yeah this is a dumb oversight an KDE Theme should be easy to download and apply!

It seems to be an common issue in Linux distros something that is overlooked but should be obvious.

1 Like

I’ve downloaded and install one by one manually as the global theme installer always failed to download all the other components.

Global themes can also break your system. They include code and there was a infamous incident where installing a one deleted the user’s home directory due to a bug.

2 Likes

Yeah I remember that one! Have thy even done anything for that to not to happen again?(besides fixing that one bug?)

Like redesigning the system so a bug can do anything other than change the theme!?

Humm… Maby i should ask that one question on the KDE forum?

@MyNameIsRichard I will quote you in that post.

Well, it’s the reason warnings have been slapped all over the get new stuff pages. I don’t think there’s a lot more they can do as it is arbitrary code.

Okey well warnings don’t fix the problem just an sign which people will ignore!
Maby the themeing system needs an re-design? To future proofing theme install making the whole theme system better and easier.

I don’t no? I’m not a coder or designer just spewing ideas.

I posted on KDE’s forum and see what thy say?
I will update when it’s posted(needs manual approval)
I’am new there so not surprising.

1 Like

Unless someone brainier than me comes up with a solution, I think it will need to execute code to do it’s job. Maybe some kind of sandbox to contain it. In any case I think theme is a bad choice of name for something that runs code.

1 Like

Yes I agree!

Here’s the link to my KDE post BTW: