EndeavourOS aims to be as close to Arch as possible, so the only way I see this happening is if Arch supports multiple init systems, which is unlikely.
There is Artix if you want to try an Arch-like with different init systems.
Yes you could do the migration but that would mean installing the repos used by Artix like World and Galaxy.
And also you would not have a AUR helper OOTB as well. And probably some more things that would be making it Artix, but not Endeavouros with another sysinit.
That wasn’t what I meant. I meant, the pointless porting of code that’s already been ported elsewhere. Ie, repeating work as busywork (but surely a learning experience of years).
To elucidate much further (and similar to what others have said), there would be absolutely no point to try to add these init systems to EndeavourOS. The sensible person would adapt another distro that has already done that, fork it, and add whatever E* bits were needed (which might require some modifications possibly).
There is another thought that comes to mind , how close can you be to vanilla ARCH without systemd , because like already mentioned Artix uses it’s own repos. And yes you can add the ARCH repos to Artix, but why would the Wiki would warn you to do that on your own risk ?
Warning: Any unofficial repositories (including Arch repositories and the AUR) are not supported by Artix Linux. Use them at your own risk. Packages in these repositories get updated at a different rate than the official ones and may break your system. If you have any problems with your system after installing packages from these repositories, you will have to solve them yourself. If you need assistance, you can ask in the forum, but don't demand any help from the developers.
Pretty much as you think, software is not guaranteed to work…use at your own risk.
You can use the Arch repositories just fine, I do on my Artix setup. Just don’t use the core repository as this can overwrite the core Artix packages. I personally don’t use Arch multilib repository as everything has been available in Lib32. I have Arch extra enabled since 2-3 main packages were not on Artix.
AUR is fine as well, the stance is the same as with Arch forums on that though.
It also helps that I update once a week and check all packages before updating. But most packages are in the Artix repositories already and you can ask in the forums to have a package added to the official ones. Any non-artix repository packages I keep an eye on each week, if any appear.
You posted the answer yourself:
Have you guys never heard of a thing called a rhetorical question ? ![]()
Nope…what would be the point of it ?![]()
But on a more serious reply, we have to assume you mean what you say, even if it seems…well…uninformed :0 The nature of textual communication without clues.
Is this a rhetorical question? ![]()
Yes
Alright, now we have heard about a thing called a rhetorical question.
Thanks for the clarification!
At least for my comment it more for anyone going through the thread really if they are not aware of how Artix manages things, and not necessarily your question directly, maybe someone reading would find it useful.
Some people (mostly newer users) get spooked by these warnings when they are not aware of the specifics of them.
To put this thing into perspective I am using Artix and have added the Arch repos and (obvious) mirrors.
When updating I got things like local package is newer then …etc. Just draw your own conclusions.
On another note this is where the Artix kernel is at.
7.0.10-artix1-1
The Arch kernel is at 7.0.11 .
Vivaldi is in extra and not in the Artix repos.
Just some examples.
When I think of EndeavourOS, I think it’s an Arch-based distro with a graphical installer which simplifies the installation and installs not much stuff aside. Artix is nearly the same, but without systemd. So, if one wants to simplify a simplified installation, I don’t know where the benefit might be to find. Hopefully not only in the used colors and the wallpapers made by some EOS-community members. Using systemd during the last years, I really learned to like that new ‘standard’, which makes it easier to work with different distros. At the same thoughts I installed dracut on other distros and made an alias for update-grub on my EndeavourOS installations.
I am sure you realized that the part of out of context quote from my post was originally a purely theoretical question and no “imprative” as it looks in your post.
Since it looks that way, the way you have quoted it and your post seems to be a reflection/comment on it and a reply to me I wanted to point it out for the record and the posterity.
Yes, I’m sure.
You’re one of the members of this community I like to read a lot. Sorry, texted communication is sometimes difficult. Because it may never happen that we meet in real life (or at least we do not know), maybe you can imagine to accept a virtual coffee or something different.
![]()
About all those different distros I see at distrowatch.com, I always wonder why many of them do exist, and what happened to most of them, when there base would be removed all of a sudden. A lot of those distros have lovely tinkered desktop environments, a few unique apps and a little bit changes in system configurations. Mostly they could be a nice desktop experience and build a nice community instead of offering a full distro, but that’s just my opinion. And yes, I appreciate the nice EndeavourOS
community.
You are right about that. Most of us come from different language/linguistic background and having a text-based communication and missing out on all the visual cues don’t always make the communication and comprehension easier.
We can just get into it with good will.
I’d be delighted, thank you!
Cheers ![]()
I would suggest installing Artix and staying with us in this forum. ![]()